The independent newspaper of the University of Iowa community since 1868

The Daily Iowan

The independent newspaper of the University of Iowa community since 1868

The Daily Iowan

The independent newspaper of the University of Iowa community since 1868

The Daily Iowan

Aaron Rodgers weighs in on controversial call in Iowa-Minnesota game

The New York Jets QB expressed disagreement with the call during an appearance on “The Pat McAfee Show” on Tuesday afternoon.
Officials+review+Cooper+DeJean%E2%80%99s+touchdown+punt+return+during+a+football+game+between+No.+24+Iowa+and+Minnesota+at+Kinnick+Stadium+in+Iowa+City+on+Saturday%2C+Oct.+21%2C+2023.+The+Golden+Gophers+defeated+the+Hawkeyes%2C+12-10.
Cody Blissett
Officials review Cooper DeJean’s touchdown punt return during a football game between No. 24 Iowa and Minnesota at Kinnick Stadium in Iowa City on Saturday, Oct. 21, 2023. The Golden Gophers defeated the Hawkeyes, 12-10.

New York Jets star quarterback Aaron Rodgers had quite a bit to say about the call during the Iowa-Minnesota game that overturned Cooper DeJean’s 54-yard punt return go-ahead  touchdown.

During one of his frequent appearances on “The Pat McAfee Show” on Tuesday afternoon,  Rodgers expressed his disagreement with the call. 

“That was the most ridiculous call that I saw last week, nothing about this says fair catch,” Rodgers said. “He’s pointing at it for his gunners to get out of the way.” 

Following Saturday’s 12-10 loss against Minnesota, Iowa players, coaches, and fans were left with more questions than answers. 

Despite a horrific offensive performance, cornerback Cooper DeJean looked to have saved the day again late in the fourth quarter. By rule, the officials reviewed the play. The video boards showed DeJean was in-bounds, and Iowa fans continued to celebrate. 

But, referee Tim O’Dey stunned everyone inside Kinnick Stadium by ruling DeJean had made an invalid fair catch signal. During his return, DeJean  made a waving motion with his left arm and pointed with his right  to tell his teammates to get away from the bouncing football. The referees ruled the motion of his left arm was illegal, resulting in a dead ball and pushing Iowa back to the 46-yard line where DeJean first recovered the punt. 

While DeJean was making his dash toward the end-zone, Minnesota players never stopped and continued to chase the 6-foot-1 defensive back. Minnesota coach PJ Fleck didn’t protest the initial no-call on the field. 

“All they were looking at was did he step out,” Rodgers said of the review. “And then they’re going to go back and waive this thing off? Absolutely ridiculous call.”

The Iowa offense couldn’t get in field goal range and lost the Floyd of Rosedale Trophy for the first time since 2014. 

Rodgers has been a part of several infamous calls himself. In 2012, while a member of the Green Bay Packers, he was involved in the dubious “Fail Mary” play against the Seattle Seahawks. 

“I feel terrible for [DeJean] and for Iowa fans,” Rodgers said. 

More to Discover
About the Contributors
Brad Schultz
Brad Schultz, Sports Reporter
(he/him/his)
Brad Schultz is a sophomore at the University of Iowa majoring in Journalism and Mass Communication with a minor in Sports Studies. This is first year working as a sports reporter and he has a deep passion and love for sports. Outside of the Daily Iowan, Brad is a contributor for Saturday Blitz, a college football site, with his content primarily covering Iowa and the Big Ten.
Cody Blissett
Cody Blissett, Visuals Editor
he/him/his
Cody Blissett is a visual editor at The Daily Iowan. He is a third year student at the University of Iowa studying cinema and screenwriting. This is his first year working for The Daily Iowan.