How bulletproof the Republican legislative agenda is in Iowa

Critics of Iowa’s Republican legislators have suggested their majority is so large they can pass bills that are unpopular among Iowans.

Members+of+the+House+congregate+in+the+House+Chamber+after+the+opening+of+the+2022+Legislative+Session+at+the+Iowa+State+Capitol+in+Des+Moines%2C+Iowa%2C+on+Monday%2C+Jan.+10%2C+2022.+Both+the+House+and+Senate+Republican+leaders+said+the+priority+of+this+session+is+to+return+tax+funds+and+address+workforce+conditions.+%28Grace+Smith%2FThe+Daily+Iowan%29

Grace Smith

Members of the House congregate in the House Chamber after the opening of the 2022 Legislative Session at the Iowa State Capitol in Des Moines, Iowa, on Monday, Jan. 10, 2022. Both the House and Senate Republican leaders said the priority of this session is to return tax funds and address workforce conditions. (Grace Smith/The Daily Iowan)

Lyle Muller, PolitiFact Iowa Editor


PolitiFact Iowa is a project of The Daily Iowan’s Ethics & Politics Initiative and PolitiFact to help you find the truth in politics.


The Iowa Legislature’s 2022 session dragged into mid-May with a stumbling block: a school voucher bill that Republican Gov. Kim Reynolds proposed to what usually has been the receptive, Republican-led House and Senate.

The voucher bill, in the Students First Act, would create 10,000 vouchers — enough for 2% of Iowa’s K-12 students — that parents could use to transfer their children from a local public school to a private school of their choice. The Senate passed the bill with only one Republican dissenter to join unanimous Democrat dissent in March but the House vote has been delayed while Republicans hammer out differences in their caucus.

Meanwhile, their opponents complain in places like social media that Republicans have forged a grip so strong on Iowa state politics that they can pass bills that are unpopular with the public. Why the claim?

Part of the answer to that question is in a Des Moines Register/Mediacom Iowa Poll, released near the end of March 2021, that showed 49% of Iowans opposed using state money otherwise intended for public schools to pay for students in private schooling, while 44% favor it. Another 7% were not sure, Selzer & Co., which conducts the Iowa Poll, reported.

The poll of 775 Iowa adults was conducted March 7-10, 2021, and had a margin of error of plus or minus 3.5 percentage points. It showed 33% of Democrats favoring and 60% opposing the voucher plan. Republicans came close to mirroring the overall results — 49% in favor and 43% opposed— while 48% of independents favored and 47% opposed the plan.

Poll comparisons indicated that Republicans had been successful convincing some Democrat and independent Iowan voters to join their cause.

A similar poll in 2017 showed 24% of Democrats favored and 71% opposed public funding for private education. Among independents, 37% favored and 57% opposed the idea, the 2017 poll shows.

Overall, 58% of Iowans opposed using state money intended for public school funds to help parents pay private schools to take their children, the 2017 poll showed. The 49% of Republicans who said in 2017 they opposed and 43% said they approved of public funding for school vouchers mirrored what was to come in the 2021 poll for Republicans. 

The 2017 poll, taken in early February when Republicans also controlled both legislative chambers and Republican Terry Branstad was governor, had 802 respondents and a margin of error of plus or minus 3.5 percentage points.

Thermostatic Public Opinion

Democrats are pushing for a political shift toward them. Part of what fuels their hope is classical political behavior that has shown voters bouncing back toward the political center, and an opposing party’s politics when they have had enough of those in power. 

“There’s a concept in polling called thermostatic public opinion, which basically means that public opinion can kind of act like a thermostat,” Christopher Budzisz, an associate professor of politics and director of the Loras College Poll at Loras College in Iowa, said in an interview. As an example, he said, if Republicans “go too conservative compared to where the public is… the public will act as a thermostat to go in the other direction.”

Christopher Wlezien, now a University of Texas political science professor, introduced the thermostatic public opinion model in a 1995 American Journal of Political Science article when he was on the University of Houston faculty. “Democratic accountability requires that the public be reasonably well-informed about policy, that the public adjusts its preferences for ‘more’ or ‘less’ policy activity in response to what policymakers actually do,” Wlezien, who earned his political science doctorate at the University of Iowa, wrote. 

Thus, Democrat President Obama’s Affordable Care Act, or Obamacare, passed the Democrat-controlled Congress in 2010 while the majority of Americans told pollsters they opposed it. Republicans then gained control of the House in the 2010 elections

Kristen Soltis Anderson, a noted Republican pollster, political researcher and commentator, wrote that Obamacare then became more popular when Republicans took power in Congress and threatened to repeal it. But Anderson, a Spring 2022 Fellow at Georgetown University’s Institute of Politics and Public Service also argued this in a January 2021 Washington Examiner article:

“Unfortunately, America’s thermostat may be broken.”

She said that not only people, but institutions in corporate business and higher education moved leftward – lurched, she wrote – in backlash against Donald Trump when he was president. A media that was less neutral grew, she wrote, but as liberals distanced themselves from Trump, conservatives moved farther in the other direction instead of toward the center.

“So while the Left is acting thermostatically in response to what they view as the extremes of Trump, the Right is acting thermostatically to what they view as the extremes of every other institution in America,” Anderson wrote.

Abortion

This is big on people’s minds as they wait for the final U.S. Supreme Court ruling in a case whose ruling was leaked to Politico and shows at least five associate justices willing to overturn the landmark ruling making abortion legal in the U.S.: Roe v. Wade. In Iowa, the Republican-led House and Senate voted last year to adopt a state constitutional amendment that says abortion is not a right guaranteed by the Iowa Constitution.

The measure must be approved using the same language in the next General Assembly, in 2023 or 2024 and then be approved by voters by simple majority in 2024 to take effect. 

Reynolds has asked the Iowa Supreme Court to overturn its decision in 2018 that said the state constitution protects abortion rights. A ruling is pending.

A Des Moines Register/Mediacom Iowa Poll reported in September 2021 that 57% of Iowans questioned said abortion should be legal in most or all cases, while 38% said abortion should be illegal in most or all cases. The other 5% said they were not sure. The poll, of 805 Iowa adults and conducted Sept. 12-15, 2021, by Selzer & Co., had a margin of error of plus or minus 3.5 percentage points.

PolitiFact recently wrote about polling on abortion, and a murky message about the true feelings of those questioned about the topic. Reasons include views on the topic being intensely personal and often paradoxical, and sometimes contradictory responses because of how the pollster asks a question, a May 5 story showed.

The Iowa Poll asked: “Which of the following comes closest to your opinion on abortion?” It offered those responding the following options: legal in all cases, legal in most cases, illegal in all cases, illegal in most cases.

More recently, the well-respected Des Moines Register/Mediacom Iowa Poll, questioned 813 Iowa adults from Feb. 28 to March 2 on several issues being decided in the Republican-held Iowa Statehouse. The poll had a margin of error of plus or minus 3.4 percentage points. Topics it covered included:

School vaccine mandates

A Republican-supported bill listed as unfinished business in the 2022 Iowa General Assembly would prohibit day care, elementary, secondary and post-secondary schools in Iowa from requiring students to have a COVID-19 vaccine. Bill opponents say school children already must be vaccinated for other health threats and that adding COVID-19 should be acceptable.

But, the Iowa Poll showed waning support for school vaccination requirements. The Register reported on March 13 that the poll showed 34% of Iowans saying school children needed to be vaccinated unless they had a doctor’s excuse. In 2015, 59% of Iowans polled had said children should be vaccinated for school. 

The 2022 poll showed 21% supporting limited exemptions and 14% supporting broad exemptions for medical or religious reasons. It showed 8% saying Iowa should have no childhood vaccination laws, while 3% were unsure.

Day care regulations

Another bill pending Reynolds’ signature would allow child care employees and substitutes who are 16 and 17 years old to work with children without adult supervision. Six Republicans in the House voted with Democrats against the bill but none in the Senate joined Democrats in opposition. The Iowa Poll found that 65% of Iowans questioned opposed such a move, 25% supported it, and 9% were not sure.

Unemployment benefits

A bill Reynolds supports that reduces state unemployment benefits from 26 to 16 weeks has passed both the House and Senate despite public opposition. Reynolds proposed the reductions earlier this year in her Condition of the State Address so supporters and opponents expect her to sign this into law. The bill also says anyone receiving unemployment benefits has to accept a job offering 90% of the worker’s previous wage after one week of unemployment benefits; 80% of the wage after three weeks on unemployment; 75% after five weeks, and 60% after eight weeks. 

The Iowa poll showed 53% opposing the benefit cuts for laid-off workers, 38% in favor and 9% undecided. 

Lower income tax rates

Iowans were mixed about this new law, effective Jan. 1, 2023, that establishes a flat 3.9% personal income tax rate for Iowans, eliminates state income tax on retirement income, and exempts some net capital gains on company stock awarded to employees. 

Those in the Iowa Poll liked the personal income tax cut, with 54% saying they approved and 38% saying they opposed it. Another 9% said they were not sure. But only 34% of those responding supported the law’s section that reduces corporate income tax rates in phases to a targeted 5.5%. More than one-half – 53% – opposed the new corporate tax plan and 13% were not sure. 

Gender identity in school sports

Participants in interscholastic sports must compete in boys’ and girls’ sports based on their sex at birth under a law signed March 3. The law is aimed at people who are transexual and want to cross over into the sport for the gender with which they identify.

The poll showed Iowans evenly split on this, with 46% in favor, 45% opposed and 9% unsure.

What this could mean for Republican power in Iowa

The question, then, gets back to whether Republicans in charge of Iowa’s government can do what they want, regardless of public opinion. Busdzisz – whose polling on state issues has drawn attention but who now focuses on local issues where Loras exists, in Dubuque, Iowa – said the jury is out on that question and how long the current Republican hold on power will last. 

“I think parties that are in dominant political positions within a structure of government can push things, and they can continue to push it.” Budzisz said. “But I do think there is an equilibrium where that thermostatic model that I mentioned, where essentially the public does at some point react.”Pointing to Anderson’s thesis on thermostatic politics, he said political decisions can extend far from the center and subsequently the far left, especially with political polarization, before an opposing political side chips away at the power of those in charge. 

“These kinds of national trends have not not been as prevalent at the state level,” he said about political polarization in Iowa that mirrors that on the national level. “But I do think it’s increasing to where you will see Iowa Republicans thinking about Iowa Democrats as they do the national Democrats, versus making a distinction between the two. And I think one and the same goes with the Iowa Democrats looking at Iowa Republicans.”


Our Sources

Kim Reynolds web page, Students First Act

PolitiFact Iowa, “Iowa’s Student First voucher bill would benefit 2 percent of Iowa school children,” by Lauren White, April 7, 2022

Iowa Legislature, Senate File 2369 and State Journal for March 30, 2022

Des Moines Register/Mediacom Iowa Poll, “Poll: Iowans favor tighter vaccination rules for kids,” by Tony Leys, Feb. 28, 2015

Des Moines Register/Mediacom Iowa Poll, “Iowa Poll: Majority oppose using public funds for private school,” by Mackenzie Ryan, Feb. 26, 2017; updated Feb. 27, 2017

Des Moines Register/Mediacom Iowa Poll, “More Iowans oppose than favor using public funds to pay for private or home schooling, Iowa Poll finds,” by Stephen Gruber-Miller and Samantha Hernandez, March 23, 2021

Des Moines Register/Mediacom Iowa Poll, “Iowa Poll: Majority of Iowans believe abortion should be legal in most or all cases,” by Stephen Gruber-Miller, Sept. 25, 2021

Des Moines Register/Mediacom Iowa Poll, “Kim Reynolds bans transgender girls from female sports, signing Republican-backed law,” by Stephen Gruber-Miller and Ian Richardson, March 3, 2022

Des Moines Register/Mediacom Iowa Poll, “The majority of Iowans support a flat income tax but not corporate tax cuts, Iowa Poll finds,” by Stephen Gruber-Miller and George Shillcock, March 9, 2022

Des Moines Register/Mediacom Iowa Poll, “Iowans are sharply divided on banning transgender girls from female sports, Iowa Poll finds,” by Ian Richardson, March 9, 2022

Des Moines Register/Mediacom Iowa Poll,Iowans’ support for non-COVID vaccine requirements in schools erodes, Iowa Poll finds,” by Tony Leys, March 13, 2022

Des Moines Register/Mediacom Iowa Poll, “Majority of Iowans oppose Gov. Kim Reynolds’ proposal to cut unemployment benefits,” by Tyler Jett, March 17, 2022

Des Moines Register/Mediacom Iowa Poll, “Iowa Poll: Nearly two in three Iowans oppose allowing 16-year-olds to work unsupervised in child care facilities,” by Kim Norvell, March 20, 2022

The Gazette (Cedar Rapids, Iowa), “Private school tuition bill may be what’s holding up Iowa Legislature’s adjournment,” by Erin Murphy, April 17, 2022

The Gazette (Cedar Rapids, Iowa), “Reduction in Iowa’s unemployment benefits headed to governor,” by Erin Murphy, April 26, 2022

The Gazette (Cedar Rapids, Iowa), “Iowa school vouchers closer to beating deadline,” by Erin Jordan, May 2, 2022

Iowa Legislature, House Joint Resolution 5 right to life amendment; House vote; Senate vote

Kim Reynolds Condition of the State Address, Jan. 11, 2022

Kim Reynolds press release, March 1, 2022

Iowa Legislature, House File 2317

Iowa Legislature, House File 2298, House File 2416, House File 2355 and House File 2198

Twitter, Adam Singer, May 2, 2022

Iowa Department of Education, “Student Health Requirements

Iowa Department of Public Health, “Iowa Immunization Requirements

PolitiFact Iowa phone interview with Christopher Budzisz, associate professor of political science and director of the Loras College Poll, Loras College, May 5, 2022

American Journal of Political Science,The Public as Thermostat: Dynamics of Preferences for Spending,” by Christopher Wlezien, University of Houston, November 1995

Christopher Wlezien faculty website, University of Texas at Austin

Washington Examiner,America’s political thermostat is broken,” by Kristen Soltis Anderson, Jan. 19, 2021

Kristen Soltis Anderson website

CNN/Opinion Research Corporation Poll, May 17-18, 2013 report that includes March 2010 figures

U.S. Dept. of Human Services, Affordable Care Act web page

U.S. Congress, H.R.3590 – Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act

Journal of the Association of American Medical Colleges, “Opposition to Obamacare: A Closer Look,” by P.R. Gordon and L. Gray, University of Arizona, A. Hollingsworth, Indiana University, E.C. Shapiro and J.E. Dalen University of Arizona; September 2017

New York Times, Election 2010 Maps

Politico, “Supreme Court has voted to overturn abortion rights, draft opinion shows,” by Josh Gerstein and Alexander Ward, May 2, 2022

Iowa Supreme Court ruling “Planned Parenthood of the Heartland and Jill Meadows vs. Kimberly K. Reynolds, ex rel, State of Iowa and Iowa Board of Medicine,” filed June 29, 2018; amended Sept. 18, 2018

Iowa Public Radio, “Abortion remains legal, but the future of abortion rights in Iowa is uncertain,” by Katarina Sostaric; May 3, 2022

PolitiFact, “Why polling about abortion hides the true complexity of what Americans think,” by Louis Jacobson, May 5, 2022

Georgetown University Institute of Politics and Public Service website

Facebook Comments