Opinion | Make Puerto Rico a state
It’s past time Puerto Rico gets the respect and dignity it deserves from the U.S. government.
October 4, 2022
When former President Donald Trump launched rolls of paper towels into a crowd of desperate victims of Hurricane Maria in 2017, it was a perfect representation of how the U.S. treats its territory of Puerto Rico — with neglect and carelessness.
Two weeks ago, Hurricane Fiona devastated the island. Thousands of people are still without power and water, and billions of dollars in damages have been caused. Just five years ago, Hurricane Maria caused even greater destruction. The response from the U.S. government was inadequate, and Puerto Rico never fully recovered as a result.
The U.S. failure to look after the people of Puerto Rico has gone on for far too long, and the federal government must treat them with the same dignity as any other part of the states.
Our failure to care for Puerto Rico is evident in our lackluster responses to its natural disasters.
For Hurricane Irma and Harvey, which hit the U.S. in the same year Hurricane Maria hit Puerto Rico, there were over 30,000 federal personnel on site in the days after landfall. Puerto Rico never even saw 20,000 personnel in the days after Hurricane Maria.
While Hurricane Maria caused around as many direct deaths as Hurricane Harvey, Maria caused almost 3,000 indirect deaths compared to 35 by Harvey.
The U.S. is more than capable of providing the relief Puerto Rico needs after disasters. Not doing so is a policy choice.
While the U.S. has claimed Puerto Rico as a territory for over 100 years, it has never granted the terroritory sufficient representation in Congress.
Puerto Rico elects a resident commissioner that stands as its authorized representative before the federal government. While the resident commissioner is technically a member of Congress, its power is far from equal to that of other members of Congress.
For example, the resident commissioner has limited voting powers. They are only allowed to vote in committees they are part of and in the final passing of any bills. In addition, there is no apportionment of districts by population, meaning the resident commissioner represents five times as many people as the average member of the House.
This lack of representation is wholly unjust and anti-democratic. If our policies and laws affect and apply equally to everyone, there is no reason why they should not have equal representation.
To fix these injustices, Puerto Rico should be granted statehood. Statehood would allow them to see billions of dollars worth of benefits instantly, such as through Medicare and Medicaid. Puerto Rico would have fair representation.
Residents of Puerto Rico pay federal taxes to the U.S. If the U.S. government is going to continue to make Puerto Ricans pay taxes, it is only fair that Puerto Ricans see a return on their taxes via benefits and assistance.
Puerto Rico is already extremely tied to the U.S. because it is a territory, so it will be able to enjoy the benefits of statehood without making too many drastic changes.
If the U.S. intends on keeping its claim to Puerto Rico as a territory, it must give Puerto Ricans the respect and decency they deserve and grant them full rights and protections as U.S. citizens through giving Puerto Rico statehood.
Columns reflect the opinions of the authors and are not necessarily those of the Editorial Board, The Daily Iowan, or other organizations in which the author may be involved.