Laursen: Who does Hall really represent?


The Daily Iowan; Photos by Josep

Ryan Hall speaks during his campaign announcement on the east steps of the Old Capitol building on the Pentacrest on Wednesday, Aug. 9, 2017. Hall is a 24 year old student who is campaigning for a seat representing District B on City Council in the upcoming November election. (Joseph Cress/The Daily Iowan)

What voters should know about Ryan Hall’s City Council campaign.

By Lucee Laursen

[email protected]

Student involvement in civic duties should be something that is encouraged. In the 2016 presidential election, only 50 percent of people ages 18-29 turned out to vote, according to the Brookings Institute. Voter turnout and civic involvement has historically been lacking, to say the least.

In the upcoming City Council election, candidate Ryan Hall has made student involvement a main piece of his platform. He is running to serve as District B’s councilor. His website states, “I am running to bridge the gap between the student population and the residents outside of campus.”

Although Hall seems to be running on a platform that will encourage student involvement, I question whom he truly represents.

In a City Council election, every resident of Iowa City is permitted to vote for each seat even if they do not reside in a particular district. Essentially, someone who lives in District B can also vote in a District C election and vice versa. This means that every resident,
including students of the University of Iowa, can vote for Hall regardless of whether he is in their district.

RELATED: UI student aims to bring student perspective to City Council

If Hall were elected, his role would be to represent the best interests of his district. District B is made up of Precincts 6, 12, 16, 17, 18, 23, 24, and 25.

“District B is mainly made up of nonstudent residents,” said Benjamin Nelson, the UI Student Government City Council liaison. “There is a large amount of student housing in District C.” Representing the student voice in a district that is not mainly made up of students fails to account for the majority nonstudent residents.

Some students and other residents think that the UI students should have a say in the council’s decisions. People believe that it is crucial that the student body is represented. Thankfully, the student body is represented by its UISG City Council liaison, who is able to voice the opinions of the student government to any city entity. This includes the City Council. Nelson regularly attends City Council meetings, and even though he cannot vote, he frequently contributes the opinions of UISG. Student opinions are well-represented on the City Council.

Even if Hall does not want to be the “student voice,” I do not think that he possesses the knowledge or ability, at this point, to represent District B on the City Council. Hall moved to Iowa City only last January. Although he has done beautiful work in the community, there is no way Hall or anyone else can accurately understand the needs of a city in nine short months. He is taking ideas from other cities’ experiences and applying them to the Iowa City area.

Hall cannot accurately represent District B well because he does not know it. This is not a personal attack on Hall. Rather, this is a column urging voters to consider if they think any person who has moved to a new city can really understand the needs of that community. I know I do not think that anyone can truly understand how Iowa City works in such a short time. But this vote is obviously not up to only me. I encourage all residents of Iowa City to vote on or before Nov. 7 and have their voices heard.

Facebook Comments